Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Domestic Workers Senate Bill 535

    Women's caucus protecting domestic workers
     I was at the House Judiciary hearing on Thursday, April 4 for SB 535 Relating to Labor.  The bill's title is Domestic Workers Bill of Rights and extends minimum wage and overtime protections to domestic service workers who had previously been exempt.  This is not an administration package bill and it is part of the Women's Caucus package.  In addition to the extension of protections of minimum wage and overtime, the measure  extends some specific civil rights protections under Chapter 378, Part I, Hawaii Revised Statutes, so Hawaii Civil Rights Commission  as well as the Wage Standards Division were there testifying in support.

     Objections
     Before the Judiciary Committee Chair Rhoads called for the vote to pass the bill out with amendments,  Representative Thielen was quite vocal about her objections to the measure.  Her focus was not whether domestic service workers should receive minimum wage and overtime as provided in Sections 3 and 4,  her objections were on the public outreach that had not been done on this measure, mostly related to the civil rights issues in Section 1 and 2.   She voted no, and convinced Representative McDermott to vote no too.

     Lack of citizen involvement
     I thought Rep Thielen's point about how few people actually track legislation and don't even hear about it until it passes was the important message.  Her main point was the effect of this measure will not impact business just families who employ people in their homes to assist in traditional family duties.  Reiterating her support of the civil union measure and her concern for her constituents Rep. Thielen expected more public discussion on the issue. 

      Comments anyone?   
      This measure, SB 535 HD2,  is going to conference committee now and is a measure the Department supports.  No one can argue that participation of the community is essential if Hawaii wants to exercise democracy as it was designed.  Comments are always welcome. (Of course, within the guidelines of the policy for this blog.)

No comments:

Post a Comment

This is a limited public forum that serves as an official community page for the Wage Standards Division, Department of Labor and Industrial Relations to share information about the work of the Wage Standards Division and related issues to the people of Hawaii and our friends outside of Hawaii.

We welcome your comment on our topic or post, but please comment with “Aloha” since this page is family friendly. Please take personal responsibility for and be respectful in your comments.


If your comment is deleted per the provisions below, you have the option of sending your comment by sending an email that does not violate any laws, or by sending a hardcopy version of your comment to the following address:



Recipient Pamela Martin
Mailing address 830 Punchbowl St., Honolulu, HI 96813

email address: Pamela.b.martin@hawaii.gov



RE: Deletion of Comments.

We will delete a comment, content, or expression (“comment”) that disrupts, disturbs, impedes, is contrary to, is inappropriate for, or interferes with function of and ability of this limited public forum to fulfill its purpose, such as a comment that is:


■Off-topic;


■Profane or sexually explicit;


■Using an offensive term that targets a specific individual(s) or groups, including a term based on race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation;


■Invasive of a person's privacy;


■A commercial solicitation or advertisement, a chain letter, or a pyramid scheme;


■Containing personal information such as a driver license number, a social security number, and other information protected by law;


■Disclosing any detail about an ongoing investigation or court or administrative proceeding that could prejudice the process or interfere with the rights or claims of a person or entity;


■Part of or is a repetitive post copied and pasted by multiple users;


■Spam or could constitute spam; and


■Speech for which content-based restrictions are permitted, including incitement, obscenity, defamation, speech integral to criminal conduct, so-called “fighting words,” child pornography, fraud, true threats, and speech presenting some grave and imminent threat the Government has the power to prevent.



This page is subject to amendment or modification at any time.



Thank you for taking the time to read this page.